My favorite place for pizza in Orlando is Rico’s Pizza. It’s what comes closest to what I enjoy for pizza.
http://ricopizza.intuitwebsites.com/
Urban Spoon entry

Rico’s is worth the trip to the south end.

A close second is House of Pizza, across from Gatorland.
http://www.orlandohouseofpizza.com/

While I have enjoyed Pizzeria Valdiano and Mellow Mushroom, Rico’s is tops. Though, in all honesty, Mellow Mushroom has no competitor, as it’s in a different category: gourmet non-traditional wacky-neat-flavor pizzas.

Kudos do go out to Pizza City in Kissimmee. That is good pizza.
Google map
UrbanSpoon entry

*begin advertising*

*end advertising*